Law enforcement agencies and medical examiners often play a crucial role in determining whether a death is suspicious. They investigate the scene, gather evidence, conduct autopsies, and analyze the circumstances surrounding the death to determine if it was the result of natural causes, an accident, suicide, or homicide. If there are indications of foul play or other unusual factors, the investigation may be escalated to a more thorough criminal investigation to establish the cause and manner of death and, if necessary, identify and prosecute those responsible. In those situations, a private investigator is often brought in to examine the evidence and uncover the truth.
What is Considered a Suspicious Death?
A suspicious death refers to situations where circumstances surrounding an individual's death raise concerns or doubts about the cause or manner of death. These circumstances might suggest that the death could be the result of foul play, criminal activity, negligence, or some other unnatural or unexpected factor. Suspicious deaths can encompass a wide range of situations, including but not limited to the following scenarios.
Learn more: 5 Manners of Death: PI's Guide to Death Investigations
Unexplained Circumstances
When there is no clear or logical explanation for the cause of death based on the available evidence, i.e. no visible wounds or trauma to the body, law enforcement may begin a suspicious death investigation.
Injuries or Trauma
Deaths involving significant injuries or trauma inconsistent with the reported cause of death or are otherwise not easily explained often require a suspicious death investigation. For example, a person who has blunt-force trauma but wasn’t reported as involved in a car accident, etc.
Lack of Medical History
If the deceased had no known medical conditions and no obvious signs of natural causes, a suspicious death investigation may be needed. A young, otherwise healthy person unexpectedly dying is very unusual and unlikely under normal circumstances.
Presence of Toxic Substances
A suspicious death investigation might be warranted if forensics identify the presence of drugs, poisons, or other toxic substances in the body that might have contributed to the death, especially if the individual was not a known drug user.
Multiple or Changing Accounts
If there are differing or inconsistent accounts of the events leading up to the death, it could raise suspicion. If police interview multiple eyewitnesses who all give differing testimonies, this can immediately raise suspicions about the death.
History of Conflict
A suspicious death investigation is likely if there is a history of disputes, conflicts, or strained relationships involving the deceased or those close to them. History of domestic abuse, stalking, harassment, and more are all indicators that the death might be suspicious.
Missing Persons
A suspicious death investigation may be warranted if the deceased was reported missing before being found dead, especially in circumstances where they wouldn't have reasonably disappeared on their own.
Signs of Struggle
Evidence of a struggle, such as defensive wounds or disarray in the surroundings, often results in a suspicious death investigation.
Unusual Timing or Location
Deaths that occur in unexpected places or at unusual times, without a clear explanation, usually require a suspicious death investigation. For example, if a person is found in a location they never visited before or wouldn’t usually be at a specific time, investigators usually take this as a sign of foul play.
Pattern of Similar Deaths
When there is a pattern of deaths with similar circumstances, it could indicate a potential serial or mass killing. An investigation is usually launched in these cases.
Inadequate Investigation
If the initial investigation into the death was not thorough or if evidence was mishandled, law enforcement will typically launch an investigation. A private investigator may be asked to step in to investigate a case of potential medical malpractice that resulted in a death, for instance.
How to Investigate a Suspicious Death Claim
Investigating a suspicious death is a complex and sensitive process that requires careful attention to detail, adherence to legal and ethical standards, and collaboration with law enforcement agencies and other professionals.
Private investigators do not always have the same access to records and resources as official law enforcement officers do. PIs must work within the bounds of the law and collaborate with official agencies to ensure a thorough and lawful investigation. Here's a general outline of how a private investigator might approach such an investigation.
Initial Assessment and Consultation
The private investigator would meet with the client, who might be a family member, friend, or legal representative of the deceased, to gather information about the circumstances surrounding the death, any concerns, and any existing evidence. This initial consultation helps the investigator understand the scope of the investigation.
Legal and Ethical Considerations
The investigator needs to ensure they have the legal authority to conduct the investigation and that they adhere to any applicable laws and regulations. They also need to respect the privacy and emotions of the deceased's loved ones.
Scene Examination
If possible, the investigator may visit the location where the death occurred. They would assess the scene for any potential evidence, inconsistencies, signs of struggle, or any other details that might help establish the cause and manner of death.
View Course: Crime Scene Reconstruction – An Introduction
Review of Available Evidence
The PI would review any available evidence, including police reports, autopsy reports, medical records, witness statements, and photographs. They would identify any gaps or inconsistencies in the information.
Interviews and Statements
The investigator would interview witnesses, family members, friends, co-workers, and anyone else who might have relevant information. These interviews aim to gather additional details, identify potential leads, and uncover any discrepancies in the accounts of events leading up to the death.
Learn more: Interview vs. Interrogation: What’s the Difference and Which Can Private Investigators Use | Statement Analysis Explained: A PI’s Guide to Finding Gaps in Statements & Testimonies
Forensic Analysis
Depending on the circumstances, the investigator might collaborate with forensic experts to analyze evidence such as toxicology reports, ballistics analysis, DNA testing, and other scientific methods that can provide insights into the cause and manner of death.
View Course: Forensics-The Five Disciplines of Evidence
Background Investigation
The investigator might look into the background of the deceased, including their personal history, relationships, financial status, and any potential conflicts that could shed light on their death.
View Course: Background Investigations-Guidelines and Procedures
Review of Medical Findings
If an autopsy was conducted, the investigator would review the autopsy report to understand the medical findings related to the cause of death and any potential contributing factors.
Collaboration with Authorities
The investigator would cooperate with law enforcement agencies and medical examiners, sharing relevant findings and information. If new evidence is uncovered that suggests criminal activity, it would be turned over to the appropriate authorities.
Documentation and Reporting
Throughout the investigation, the investigator would meticulously document their findings, including witness statements, photographs, records, and any other evidence. They would compile their findings into a comprehensive report for their client.
Legal Proceedings
If the investigation reveals evidence of foul play or criminal activity, the investigator might assist in preparing for legal proceedings, including providing testimony if necessary.
Learn more: Tips for Testifying in Court: How to be an Effective Witness
What Are The Common Results of a Suspicious Death Investigation?
The results of a suspicious death investigation can vary widely depending on the circumstances, evidence gathered, and the goals of the investigation.
Natural Causes
In some cases, a thorough investigation might conclude that the death was indeed due to natural causes. This determination could be based on medical evidence, autopsy findings, and a comprehensive review of the circumstances.
Accidental Death
If the investigation reveals that the death was the result of an accident, the findings could provide a clear understanding of how the accident occurred, the factors involved, and whether any negligence or contributing factors were present.
Suicide
If the evidence supports the conclusion that the death was a suicide, the investigation might provide insights into the individual's mental state, any potential triggers, and the circumstances leading up to the tragic event.
Homicide
If the investigation uncovers evidence of foul play, the findings could lead to a determination of homicide. This might involve identifying potential suspects, establishing motives, and providing evidence to support criminal charges.
Open Case
In some cases, the investigation might not yield conclusive results, leaving the cause and manner of death undetermined. This could happen if the evidence is inconclusive or if the circumstances are complex and require further analysis.
New Evidence
A suspicious death investigation might uncover new evidence that prompts law enforcement agencies to reopen a cold case or revise their initial conclusions about the cause of death.
Legal Proceedings
Depending on the findings, the results of the investigation could lead to legal actions, such as criminal charges against suspects or civil lawsuits.
Closure for Family and Friends
Regardless of the outcome, a thorough investigation can provide closure and a sense of clarity for the family and friends of the deceased. Understanding the circumstances surrounding the death can help them process their grief and move forward.
Policy and Procedure Changes
In cases where negligence or procedural failures are identified, the investigation results could lead to changes in policies, procedures, or safety measures to prevent similar incidents in the future.
Final Thoughts
Private investigators are often crucial in cases involving a suspicious death, helping law enforcement uncover new evidence and families receive closure about the loss of a loved one. If you’re a private investigator who wants to enrich your career and make a difference by investigating suspicious deaths, check out our continuing education course for PIs which covers death investigation, suspicious death criteria, and more. NITA is your partner for on-demand continuing education and professional development for private investigators. Learn online, at your own pace, and bolster your career as a private investigator.
View Course: How to Investigate a Suspicious Death Claim →
You might also like:
Our enrollment counselors are here to answer any questions you might have about our state- and board-approved status, pre-licensing training, or professional development programs.
